One of the key rituals in my classroom is the use of line-ups. Inspired by Building Thinking Classrooms in Mathematics by Peter Liljedahl, I began incorporating this strategy at the start of class to form randomized groups. This approach aligns with the BTC model of randomized grouping while also giving students the chance to interact with everyone in the class.
Over time, this ritual has fostered a strong sense of classroom community and reinforced the value of truly random grouping. Students enjoy the variety of prompts I use and appreciate the opportunity to meet and collaborate with different peers each day. As a result, the classroom environment has become more positive and supportive, where students feel safe to take risks, make mistakes, and learn from one another.
Here are a few of the prompts that I use to line up my students:
In the 1980s, when I attended high school at Alhambra here on the west side of Phoenix, I had an amazing teacher for three of my classes: Mrs. Janet Moore. She taught sophomore and senior level English, and also the Humanities course I took in senior year. Though she passed away years ago, I can’t express how much she meant (and still means) to me.
One of Mrs. Moore’s gifts was to bring a sense of humanity and richness to our learning experiences. Whether it was encouraging us to explore alternative texts for our essays, or providing enrichment resources, she was always a gentle soul who made learning fun, and placed our lessons within the broader human context.
One day in Humanities class we were discussing the different attitudes toward discursive thought, as expressed in some Western and Eastern philosophies. Without “othering” Asian cultures, Mrs. Moore introduced and mediated discussions on the richness of views of meditation, koans, satori and kensho, and instruction through parables. She contrasted these with ideals of discursive thought and disputation, and placed them beside concepts of “Being” from Aristotle and Heidegger. In the context of this discussion, she recounted a Zen koan – which I later learned was told about the Zen master Hakuin – that went roughly like this:
One day, a warrior traveled far and climbed a tall mountain to speak to a venerable monk to learn the secrets of the afterlife. When he arrived, he approached the old man meditating in his garden, and asked him “Tell me, sage: where are the Gates to Heaven and Hell?”
At this, the monk opened his eyes to look at the warrior, and said “Who are you to ask about the Gates of Paradise? You look like a beggar!”
Angry with the insult to his pride, the warrior drew his sword and held it to the chest of the seated monk. “You will answer me, or I will kill you!” he shouted.
At this, the old monk said calmly “Here open the Gates to Hell.”
The warrior, taken aback by this, was silent for a moment. He then sheathed his sword as he calmed, recognizing the discipline of the sage.
The monk then smiled and said “Here open the Gates to Heaven.”
To this day, almost exactly forty years later, I still recall vividly the long, awed silence that persisted in class after Mrs. Moore spoke the final line of the koan. It has endured in my consciousness and resurfaced many, many times since then.
I mention this because the theme for today’s post is “Portals and Thresholds”. Mrs. Moore exemplifies the ideal educator for me, in the way she was constantly opening portals into new ways of thinking, and gently guiding us to those thresholds of learning and expanding our understanding. When I think of a model of the kind of educator I want to be, she is the epitome. And this koan beautifully illustrates the opportunity each of us has, in any given moment, to choose by our actions to open a portal that is constructive or destructive, and of meeting each student where they are, and differentiating our pedagogy to their respective needs so that each may walk through that portal without hindrance.
I try to apply Mrs. Moore’s modeling in my instructional area of Chemistry, a field which may not immediately strike many as synonymous with empathy and the human-centered dimensions of knowledge. Or at least, not in the way that, for example, the arts or humanities fields might. Our tendency in the STEM fields is sometimes to focus more on the precision, the exactitude, and the processes and the systems of our work – that is, the more cognitive components – and give less attention to the equally important affective, social, and behavioral components of learning (as well as practicing) in our fields. The arts do a much better job of this than we do in STEM, frankly.
It’s not to say we STEM instructors are unempathetic. My colleagues are some of the most empathetic people I know! Rather, I would argue that we have models of instruction that we have all learned which emphasize more strongly the cognitive components of learning, such that the affective, social and behavioral components sometimes have to be grafted on after the fact. And this grafting-on sometimes only happens once we engage in significant professional development and self-interrogation.
The way I teach Chemistry today is sometimes quite different from how I learned it from some of my Old School professors and teachers. In the 1980s, most of my college professors were in their late middle-age. Most of them had gone to college in the 1950s and were taught by professors who had themselves attended college in the 1920s. It showed, with some taking a “sink or swim” attitude with their students. (Worse, I also saw one tear up students’ papers in front of class, shout at their students, and throw erasers and chalk, upbraiding them in front of the class, and so forth. All abusive behaviors, but which were rather more acceptable “back in the day”.) Others were not abusive like this, but were merely distant and aloof. A pervasive attitude seemed to be that it was the professor’s responsibility to provide the structured content expertise, and the student’s responsibility to provide everything else, including the emotional engagement with the learning experience.
Don’t get me wrong: some of my professors were more engaged. A couple were even excellent! And students absolutely have to bring their own intrinsic motivation and executive function to the learning process. But effective instructors have a greater responsibility than just providing structured content expertise. We must also exercise appropriate affective engagement. Pedagogical soundness and excellence sometimes requires we be coaches, nurturers, facilitators, and gentle guides who – while championing academic rigor and integrity – also recognize that we do not work in a vacuum, and students bring their lives with them into our classroom. The notion that they should just “leave all that outside” is unrealistic.
This is particularly true when our students are experiencing so many challenges, one of the most pernicious of which is socioeconomic disadvantage. Having grown up as a first generation student in a poor household led, for much of my youth, by a single mom, this is particularly resonant for me. Unless someone has experienced this for themselves, it may be difficult to imagine how pervasive the impacts are for a student doing their best to manage home, work, and school under financial precarity. We hear about some students who may have been evicted from their homes, or who have a parent in prison, or who have to work two jobs while attending college, or who have difficulty affording child care, or transportation, or groceries, or medicine. But unless you have lived that life, it may be impossible to fully appreciate just how ground down this makes you feel, and how hard even the simplest things become. These challenges absolutely do not sit and wait at the threshold of the learning experience; rather, they are integral to the student’s experience of their world entire, and cannot be extricated from their learning.
So I am thankful that we, as a profession – and particularly in the community college context this is the case – have embraced a much more intentionally holistic approach to student engagement, which goes far beyond simply “providing expert content knowledge in a structured format”. Rather, we engage in helping lead students to the thresholds of learning, even when that means we need to differentiate our approach to meet their particular needs. When we find ourselves turning a blind eye to student needs or systemic disadvantage, even when it is in a well-intentioned effort to provide a “neutral” learning experience, we passively participate in an unjust system. There, I believe, open the Gates to Hell. But when we take it as part of our responsibility as educators to understand and work in appropriate ways to ameliorate the inequities that our students experience, there open the Gates to Heaven.
Well, I’m still searching for the Gates to Heaven as an educator. But every time I find myself empathizing with my students, respecting their individuality and trying to understand their perspectives and adapting to their needs – while maintaining the academic rigor of my teaching – I feel like I get a little glimpse of it. Every time I try to bring in the human dimensions of Chemistry, whether it is to reflect on climate impact, the geopolitical ramifications of sourcing raw materials, ideas in the philosophy of science, the intersectionality of race and gender in the historical practice of the sciences, or other relevant social dimensions, I feel like I present new thresholds for my students to gain deeper understanding of Chemistry in their lives and in the world beyond simply “can you solve this equation” or “can you name this compound”. And in so doing, I feel like I approach a little closer to the platonic ideal of what a chemistry course could be.
As I am now in the final decade of my career, I find that this is the area in which I am most excited to develop as an educator, and as a human being sharing this journey with you all.
And I wish I could talk about all this with Mrs. Moore today.
When I’m traveling — if I’m driving — I don’t choose the scenic route unless it’s a relatively quick trip (speaking metaphorically). Otherwise, it’s Interstate all the way, baby. As fast as I can go. No, we can’t stop and see that scenic spot even though we’ve driven by it 20 times and we’re ahead of schedule. I’m trying to get a lot done, and to be very honest, I’ve asked to do it. I’ve made promises and I’m looking forward to keeping them so I need the “Freeway” to get things done efficiently, so there will be times when the Interstate is the best access to accomplish my goals that week. So, when I write about transitions, pathways, and doors, as was suggested as an alternative, I realized, the rest of the time, when I’m not whizzing by, I do take the scenic route, because I think that leads to understanding the given subject.
I’m going to choose both options for this writing – the scenic route and the Interstate because I’m engaging students through our GCC Canvas website and I want it to be inviting, comfortable, and visually appealing – and yet have the access of going through a lot of important and relevant material. I want my students to feel that this course is where they would really would like to spend their time each week and just listen to music and, hopefully, think about what they’re listening to.
So many people think that by studying or learning about Bach and Mozart will make them smarter, especially as children. That’s not how it works. Music helps them learn how to use their brains in new ways — and can work in virtually any genre, especially if you show the influences of that genre.
I have had students who were heavily into STEM or specifically Math or Science, who told me at the end of class, “This course was the only thing that kept me sane because I had such a heavy workload. I looked forward to working on this class and learning about music. I didn’t know what it would be like, but it became so much more, and was just what I needed. Thank you for offering a place where learning could be comfortable and I could share my thoughts about what we were listening to, and learningabout.” Those kinds of comments are what I live for. To me, it’s what teaching is all about. Connecting and knowing that you have connected.
Moving on to doors, I have two specific images that I like to use that I think makes students think “it’s open, let’s go in.” I’m hoping that’s what they’re thinking. Before the semester begins, students are practically begging to get in, so I hope that these two visual elements help to welcome them. (When I taught in the classroom, I never had people try to “learn early,” but it seems to be something that they do in asynchronous classes, and I don’t blame them.) When I’m working asynchronously, I’m trying to get a jump on things as well, because I know how many deadlines I have coming down the pike, and how many decisions – artistic, educational, health wise, semester-wise are coming that I need to be on the job “working the problem.”
The idea is to invite students each week with more visual elements. I usually start with the photo above in week one. Somewhere later, I usually include this next one.
Regarding transitions, I just finished a book the other day by Mark Rashid, Horses Never Lie, (Simon and Schuster), and I thought how appropriate to come across this for my life and my teaching at this moment.
It was meant to show people how to be “soft” when riding a horse. You don’t need to jerk them around and try to be “the boss,” or to “dominate,” but you can gently guide them with light cues, allowing the horse to decide what to do. They have a wealth of information that they’ve often been taught and the author thought, as he was trying to get a particular horse to do something, “this horse knows what to do,” so subtlety will help better than a firm hand in order to let him figure it out.
And I thought, this is exactly what I’m trying to do with my students. I give them certain information, then we listen to exemplify that. I often ask them to share a piece with the rest of the class, and I ask them to discuss what and why they chose the music they included and what they thought of others choices as well. “Soft.” The metaphor may not be what they, as students, would use to describe what they’re doing, but I know they can do it – just like the horse usually knows what he/she is supposed to do. I ask them to keep their comments positive, and I think they appreciate that because they know they’ll be treated the same way with their choices. No judgement. Their opinion is honored.
We’ve already talked about the requirements for writing cues, so as the educator, I give them time to figure it out based on what I offer as prompts. And I’m willing to offer as many prompts as they need.
I had just finished reading this and I thought “I need to read more by this author because I think he’s on to something.” It allows students (and riders) to be more creative, to use their knowledge and what they’re learning about in the course, and all of the learning they’ve amassed up to this point. I used to tell my students (I don’t usually do this anymore) “you already know so much about music because you have so much music available to listen to.” I don’t say it anymore, because I think it’s obvious. Perhaps not.
Here is Yellow Horse, a very wise 22-year old Palomino, who has cotton candy for his forelock. Over the years, he has taught me the meaning of being soft in my prompts and cues. I rarely have to do much of anything. He’s so attuned to everything and is such a joy. I hope that I can bring more of that to my students.
Thirty-five years ago, I stepped into my first classroom at Deer Valley HS with a mix of excitement and maybe a little bit of terror. It was a high school classroom after all. Teenagers are scary. I had my lesson plans meticulously typed (on actual paper, mind you), and I was raring to go. Today, as I begin the process of winding down my career, I find myself reflecting on the moments, big and small, that have made this journey unforgettable.
When I started teaching, the idea of an online class seemed about as futuristic as video calls, making calls with your watch, and flying cars. Remember the Jetsons!? Over the years, I’ve adapted to hybrid learning, digital platforms, and yes, even Instagram and Twitter posts for assignments. From overhead projectors and chalkboards to Smartboards and AI-powered tutoring, the landscape of education has transformed in ways I never could have predicted. I remember sitting on a desk with a bunch of other faculty at Westwood HS in 1993 discussing the World Wide Web and how it could possibly change education. Wow! We had no idea!
Educause 2007 Alisa and Mary Jane Onnen
There have been moments of brilliance, moments of comedy, and moments of sheer chaos in those 35 years. And somewhere along the way, I became part-instructional designer, part-IT support, and part-time coach. Who knew that I’d one day be troubleshooting WiFi issues while also trying to explain the nuances of APA documentation. Even in a digital world, nothing replaces a well-timed pep talk, an encouraging email, or a spontaneous laugh shared over a technical glitch. “Just turn it off and restart that computer.” That used to fix it every time.
I’ve learned that students are more engaged when they feel heard, whether that’s through a discussion board post at 2 a.m. or an impromptu debate over whether a particular sentence is a run-on or not. Who argues with their English teacher about that? Navigating the world of Zoom, breakout rooms, and “Can everyone hear me?” moments has been a learning curve, but one that ultimately expanded the reach of education way before Covid.
I will miss the energy of a classroom deep in discussion, the playful groans when I announce a group project, and the pride in a student’s eyes when they realize they’ve written something truly great. I’ll miss the camaraderie of my colleagues and the sense of being part of something bigger than myself. Teaching has never been just a job; it’s been a calling, a community, and sometimes, let’s be honest, a bit of a circus. But I’m not done yet. I think I’ll stick around for at least one more year and give “just teaching” a try. No leading a committee, no painfully maneuvering through a software purchase, no trainings, no leading ecourses. Just teaching.
My doorway is the metaphoric kind. I’m a temp in A&R at our North campus. One of my most important tasks is greeting new and potential students.
In a demographic where many of our students had/have a mother figure with the resources to stay home with their children, we have noted that some students require a more nurturing environment than expected. Fortunately, we are afforded this luxury at North due to our lower population of students.
From my doorway, each student is greeted with a warm smile and an invitation to sit down. This disarms a nervous student. It seems these students are a little more open to learning what I have to teach once they feel safe and get their bearings a bit. For many of these students, it’s the first time they have control over their education, a powerful and inspiring shift.
Two of North’s student temp workers, Andy Orosco and Warloli Hevi
For another lot of these students, they still do not.
We have a lot of parents accompanying the student to register, receive guidance, and enroll. These students can be adults or otherwise. The parent speaks in a lot of cases. They are also a significant part of decision-making during this process.
Through my doorway, the student is addressed and encouraged to speak for themselves. I have seen first-hand instantaneous empowerment when this theory is applied. They sit up straighter and offer more eye contact. The expression on their faces turns from disinterest and dread to engagement and excitement, a testament to the transformative influence of student empowerment.
Some parents are reluctant to let go of control over their children’s lives. They may even express their discomfort to me. It’s natural for a parent to have doubts about their children’s ability “to adult.” In particular, the student who has been closely guided through their formative years.
Inside my doorway, their concerns are gently addressed as well.
It’s controversial to handhold for a college student. Along with literature and history, we teach personal responsibility, and handholding doesn’t seem conducive to our goal of each student achieving independence. However, I see it as a transfer of power so-to-speak. After this, students such as these feel the freedom to take that power back on their own.
For many of these students, it’s the first time they have control over their education, a powerful and inspiring shift.
These students may feel like this is easier than taking their power from those who gave life and allowed for this comfortable first 18 years. This is where a student can also enjoy the magical discovery that knowledge leads to independence. And that knowledge itself is power.
My background is in the spa industry. I won’t presume to know the science and art behind education, but I know how to make people comfortable and allow them to relax. We all need to be assured relaxation is okay at any particular moment. A consequence of productivity expectations, I suppose. It’s an expectation of any progressive society, but it doesn’t encourage an expectation of openness and vulnerability. Two things that could contribute to effective learning, I would imagine.
While these ideas are apparent and second nature to those with education and experience in academia, it was fun to discover these things on my own. To think all those years of giving massages, removing regretful tattoos, and making America beautiful one facial at a time would be training for welcoming young men and women into one of the most thrilling phases of their lives. What a delightful honor I feel, here, inside my metaphorical doorway.
The student educational journey is filled with important milestones and new thresholds that they pass on a regular basis. It’s our job as educators to help them navigate each new step. So, let’s have a frank conversation about what that even means to us as Student Success professionals.
At the community college, students come to us from all stages in their lives. We encounter the new-to-college student who just turned 18, experiencing adulthood for the first time, all the way to seasoned adults coming back to reeducate for a new career or promotion. No matter where they come from or at what stage of life they are in, every single one of them is looking to us to help them navigate these milestones. The million-dollar question is always: How?
The simplest answer is, there isn’t one way. Years of student service tells us that national best practices and strategies in student success always comes down to the amount of human interaction we can give to our students. What makes a Guided Pathway model so successful is not just the concept of gathering similar academic programs into one cohesive group, it’s the experience the student has with the advisor in that area who helps them to explore their options. The online FAFSA form students and their parents can fill out within minutes isn’t what helps them to feel confident in their ability to fund their education, it’s the financial aid representative that takes the time to explain the process. Even early alert systems with their ability to help us flag students in crisis are meaningless without the person reaching out to the student to discuss their issues. Academia is great at thinking up innovative strategy to approach student success, but each student and their journey is unique. Implementing strategy is never enough, it inevitably comes down to the that one person on campus interacting with the student, that often times yields the best results.
Like I said before, the student’s journey is a collection of milestones and thresholds. They encounter something new in almost every step of the way. When we work with a student it’s our job to assess in that moment where the student is coming from, what is the issue, and how best can we help. Active listening is paramount to understanding and allowing the student to fully explain or express their questions or concerns before we start telling them the solution. Listening is essential to not only giving the most accurate info, but to also validate who they are and what they are dealing with. In our experience, most students, when they walk into our spaces seeking our help, are just looking for that connection. They are more than ok when we tell them we don’t have an answer for them. Often times our best tool is to sit and listen. Getting to know our students is the first step in providing the right kind of help at the right time.
As a rule, we encourage our students to come back and see us multiple times a semester, not because we feel they need tracking, but because we get to know them and vice versa. Each visit is an opportunity to cultivate mutual respect and trust. Before long the student feels comfortable coming to us when they don’t understand something or encounter a new experience. Our relationship allows us to help them navigate in a way that makes sense and in a manner that makes sense. Which then equates to a better student experience overall. They aren’t intimidated by something new, because they know they have allies who can help them through it.
I challenge you to get to know your students, to evaluate your processes and put student learning and experience at the center of your decisions. Can we take our time during these interactions to allow for better understanding? Can we relate our own stories to help us connect to their experience? Can we remind ourselves that our interaction with our students is the purpose of our work?
When offered the prompt this week to write about doors as a metaphor in education, my mind immediately went to the doors I’ve seen on the Camino de Santiago, a thousand-year-old matrix of pilgrimage paths winding through Spain, Portugal, and France.
The doors I’ve encountered on the Camino have a magical quality, and I am often left wondering, “What is on the other side?”
Rabanal del Camino, Spain
This spring, GCC will graduate its first baccalaureate class of elementary and special education students. I had the honor of teaching their first-semester Educational Psychology course in fall of 2023, and this semester I am teaching the Professional Seminar course as these same students complete their student teaching.
As I think about it, so much of what I do is try to explain to these students what’s on the other side of the “teaching door.” I want to preview for them both the joys and pains that are part of this venerable profession. I want to flag potential pitfalls without scaring my students away. I want to share all the reasons why becoming a teacher was the best decision I ever accidentally fell into.
Very often, my students envision the door to the teaching world lined with roses, perhaps with a set of charming stone steps leading to their entry:
Riego de Ambros, Spain
And others have in mind a more slapped-together entrance like the doorframe of this iconic bar on the Camino:
El Ganso, Spain
And still others envision a combination of whimsy and reality:
Povoa de Varzim, Portugal
But as much as I want to forecast for them what they might experience in their first years of teaching, they will only really know when they cross the threshold to their own classrooms.
By establishing a teacher preparation pathway, GCC has opened the door for many students who might not have otherwise sought teacher certification. (And what Heather Merrill and her team have done to create this opportunity for students is nothing short of magic!) As a result, we professors now hold the door for our soon-to-be graduates as they take over in the profession where some of us began many years ago.
May what these new teachers find on the other side of the classroom door be nothing less than the stuff of their teaching dreams!
The funny thing about tacit knowledge is that you have to know what the word “tacit” means. Dale Carnegie tells us that it is good to share your inadequacies before you hand out advice. So here I am at the grand ole age of 56 and I had to lean on Siri for a good explanation of the word tacit. Maybe they just did not include that in my Irish elementary school curriculum.
I have officially attended three Literacy Partner-style trainings now, and have learned all about our expert dilemma of unconscious competence and how it affects the students we are teaching. It made sense to me that there are things that we inherently know and we forget to take the time to tell people how we arrived at this high state of knowledge. We might think “well, if they had XYZ class, or attended high school, they should just know. Right?”
Not so fast.
I doubled down on the blindspot training sessions, and I went back to my course assignments and fixed a few things that were not implicit in directions, rubrics and such. I scaffolded my lessons. I added more low stakes tests. Students were doing better on the high stakes assignments. I felt pretty good about the clarity I was providing.
What really turned on the light bulb for me, however, was not in addressing HOW I am teaching, but in HOW I CAME TO KNOW the information that I am teaching.
Ohhhhhhh! That totally makes sense now! And the lightbulb goes on!
When Dr. Michelle Yeo presented at the District Day of Learning about student blind spots, and tacit knowledge, the Literacy Partner training finally kicked in. I was not asking myself one basic question that changed everything. I was not asking myself how I came up with the necessary knowledge to problem solve in my field. I was simply trying to simplify with learning tools and steps.
An example of this tacit knowledge scenario is when my darling husband tries to simplify information for my benefit, he often repeats his information several times because it is clearly logical to him, and maybe I am just not hearing him correctly. We forget that we have years of life experiences, education and personal interests that brought us to this point. We have literally embodied the information that we assume others should know.
I will continue to contemplate this process of how I came to know things. I will practice using the word tacit in a sentence, and the next time someone uses it in a sentence I won’t have to pull out my phone and get distracted from the actual point of their message!
As a big fan of renovation, I was ecstatic when given the opportunity to design an entryway. To me, an entryway should do more than serve as a passage—it should set the tone for the entire space, welcoming everyone who crosses its threshold. I wanted my entryway to embody four key principles: a welcoming atmosphere, inclusivity and accessibility, community and engagement, and a future-focused approach. It is important to note that I was dreaming big and made this more of a building on campus rather than a singular classroom.
A Welcoming Atmosphere
The moment someone steps into the space, they should feel a sense of warmth and inspiration. High ceilings and ample natural light create an open, airy environment that invites people in. Vibrant murals would adorn the walls, encouraging thought, conversation, and curiosity. These artistic elements would not only beautify the space but also challenge visitors to think critically and engage with the environment in a meaningful way.
Inclusivity and Accessibility
A truly inclusive entryway must cater to the needs of all individuals. Seating would be available at various heights to accommodate different comfort levels, and designated spaces would allow for wheelchair accessibility. Additionally, built-in technological features, such as easily accessible charging stations and device-friendly seating areas, would ensure that everyone has the resources they need to stay connected and engaged.
Community and Engagement
An entryway should reflect the people who pass through it. To foster a strong sense of community, I would incorporate a dedicated gallery space showcasing student and faculty work. From research projects to faculty innovations, this area would celebrate the contributions of those who make the institution thrive. By highlighting their achievements, the entryway would serve as a hub of creativity and intellectual exchange.
Future-Focused Design
The future of education and community spaces lies in sustainability and technological integration. This entryway would feature digital resource kiosks, providing real-time updates on events and opportunities. Eco-friendly elements, such as living plant walls, energy-efficient lighting, and sustainable furniture, would emphasize a commitment to environmental responsibility. Natural light would further reduce the need for artificial lighting, creating a harmonious balance between innovation and sustainability.
By designing an entryway with these principles in mind, I aim to create a space that is more than just a doorway—it is an experience. A place that welcomes, includes, engages, and inspires all who step inside. Whether through art, accessibility, community, or sustainability, this entryway would reflect the values that matter most to me and the broader community it serves.
For the past few years I’ve been looking at the role of artificial intelligence. As a teacher of critical thinking and English composition, I have lots of questions. I consider myself a real novice in this area. I’m reading a lot, but I’ve only really used Grammarly and ChatGPT.
I’ve wanted to share my questions and my process with my students, but I worried about the Pandora’s box. Will they stop thinking? Will they stop writing?
I’ve been fortunate to have colleagues to help me on this journey.
Michelle Petry, GCC librarian, is embedded in my ENG102 class and we plan together every two weeks. Michelle is the Library Liaison for Fitness and Wellness, and my contextualized courses are part of that FOI.
Last year I had the chance to evaluate some OER materials from MIT, and she helped look at them through the information literacy lens. We crafted some assignments to help students begin to ask questions about misinformation and disinformation. These worked well with the questions I used the first day in class to start the AI discussion:
What is artificial intelligence or AI?
What should I know as a student and as an informed citizen?
Why are companies investing billions of dollars in AI?
How can I use AI most effectively?
We’ve modified some ENG102 topic exploration assignments to actually ask ChatGPT questions. Students are now comparing database searches and ChatGPT transcripts as they identify key words related to the issue they’re exploring.
The final project in ENG102 is a reflection on the research exploration process. We’ve added AI and ChatGPT to the reflection topics.
Here are some student responses. Do you believe that they’re thinking critically? Let me know.
The only times I used ChatGPT for my scholarly investigation was during the Reflection on ChatGPT where I spent some time practicing with ChatGPT to see its capabilities and when trying to come up with keywords to input into my advanced search for sources. It’s a great place to start a scholarly investigation because it is able to come up with a handful of ideas for you to branch off of but it’s not seen as a reliable source of information because it’s not always credible.
ChatGPT is a great implementation and very useful. It helped me brainstorm ideas and key terms and find specific aspects of my scholarly investigation. ChatGPT helped me identify the cause and who can make a change in my proposal argument; it gave me a general idea of where to start looking. Overall, it helped me get started, like a push start towards my research. However, I don’t believe ChatGPT can be used as a reliable source. Instead, it should be used for preliminary research but not as a source to cite.
ChatGPT was extremely beneficial to me in generating ideas for my scholarly investigation. When I began exploring my topic, I didn’t have much background knowledge. By discussing it with ChatGPT, I gained a better understanding . . . However, it’s essential to remember that ChatGPT is not a reliable source; it’s simply a starting point.
During my research process I used ChatGPT as an assistant in verifying the effectiveness of my sources. I did this by asking questions regarding the incorporation of my sources into my research paper. When asking what websites are most credible when talking about physical activity amongst youth, the CDC and the WHO popped up as most relevant when speaking about youth obesity/physical activity. This is a good thing on my part because I already had the sources that were being suggested to me.
I’m grateful to Michelle’s expertise as we continually ask questions about AI. It makes me feel more confident as I model strategies for my students. If you’d like to have your own librarian as a partner in your teaching, look at the Faculty Resources.